Group members : Lintao Xue, Carly, Megha
Is this plagiarism or not?
- Directions: Read the following scenarios and decide whether it is a case of plagiarism or
not. (Y or N) and explain why.
__Y___ 1. Kyoko needs to write a report on American politics. She looks up Barack Obama in
Wikipedia and discovers he is the 44th president of the United States. She includes this
information in her report but doesn’t mention Wikipedia.
- Yes because she doesn’t mention the source.
___Y__2. Tam is writing a paper on a novel for his English class. Since the whole class is reading
the same book, he doesn’t need to use a citation.
- Yes, In formal writing you have to cite your sources.
__N___3. Sugi wrote a paper for his European history class last semester and got an A on the
paper. This semester, his Political Science class is addressing some of the same issues that are in
his History paper. He checks with his professor first who agrees with Sugi, so he uses the
material from his History paper.
- No, the professor has allowed him to use the material.
___Y__4. Ramiro, Stephan, April, and Chris are working on a group project. Chris submits his
work and the others suspect that some of it came from the Internet, but it sounds good, so they
submit it.
- Yes, Because Chris used information from the internet without proper citations.
___N__5. Maria finds a lot of good information for her paper on the Internet. She carefully
changes the wording and prepares a good paraphrase. She doesn’t copy anything verbatim.
- No, Because Maria changed the wording and prepared a good paraphrase.
- Directions: Decide whether the information described in each scenario will require
citation of the source (Y or N) and explain why.
__N___1. You clearly identify the source at the beginning of a paragraph that summarizes the
author’s ideas about teenage drinking. Since readers will naturally assume all of the ideas in
the paragraph are from the source, no additional citation is necessary.
- If the source is clearly identified in the beginning, no other citation is necessary.
____N_2. In your paper on the history of aviation you state the date of the Wright brothers’ first
successful flight at Kitty Hawk.
The date falls under common knowledge and cited by multiple sources.
___N__3. In a paper on the civil rights movement you find some general, well-known background
information in an encyclopedia. It is obviously common knowledge, so you copy the
information and include it in your paper.
- No, because this is common knowledge.
___N__4. You ask your mother about the steps she went through in obtaining a bank loan for a
new car. You include this information in your paper.
- No, because this information was obtained from family members.
_____5. You skim a 325-page book entitled Using the Internet. A major theme throughout the
book is that the Internet is an important technological achievement. You include this in your
Paper.
- No, you’re allowed to have the same opinions as others.
_____6. You find an article that takes the same position you have taken on the subject of gun
control. To save time you summarize in your paper a portion of the argument from the article,
since the author’s ideas are identical to your own.
- Kind of, depends on how you state your position and word it.
(Excerpts above are from the following text: Clines, R.H & Cobb, E. R. (2012) Research Writing
Simplified, 7th Edition. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson.